1974 LSF Tournament
December 1974 American Aircraft Modeler
I remember back in the 1970s when I first got into
radio control flying, one of my planned accomplishments for life was to polish my glider flying skills
to the point that I could earn an LSF Level 5 rank. Well, here I am at 52 and am lucky to get in a 20-minute
thermal on a good day. The reason for not attaining the lofty goal could blamed on lack of time, lack
of money, lack of opportunity, and lack of a lot of things, but the real cause is lack of commitment.
The guys who occupy the top slots are there because they have sacrificed other things in order to be
the best at RC soaring. It was as true in 1974 as it is today in (gasp) 2011!
In this December
1974 coverage of the League of Silent Flight Tournament, Mark Smith emerges as the winner and debuts
with his self-designed Windfree glider. He later marketed the Windfree (99" wingspan) and the Windward
(72" wingspan) as part of his Mark's Models business. I have built and flown (and crashed) both.
by Patrick H. Potega (Preface by Paul Denson)
back when soaring was in its infancy on the West Coast, a group of hardy souls from the San Francisco
area felt that it would be a good thing to introduce to the world a fabulous way to get people together
for soaring fun. They organized the LSF.
The League of Silent Flight was formed to provide a
collective identification for soaring enthusiasts throughout the world and to recognize their accomplishments
through a defined program of performance with RC model sailplanes. LSF was not intended to be a club,
but a group offering a chance for men and women to get together in sporting and competitive soaring
There are no dues in the LSF; you cannot buy your way into this group. You must earn
your way in and up through five levels by accomplishing a series of tasks which increase in difficulty.
The first tournament of this elite unit was held in 1970 (Aug. 29-30, to be exact). The Nelson
family of full-size and model glider fame opened up their gliderport, "Hummingbird Haven" in Livermore,
Calif., to 85 contestants. The North and South Bay Soaring Societies cosponsored the meet. Les Anderson
walked away with the No.1 spot in the No.1 contest.
In 1971, more than 100 SFers returned to
Livermore for a second year. Would you believe that there was a five-way tie for first, until Rick Walters
nosed out John Donaldson? Le Gray astounded the group with his rare wit and dry humor at the banquet.
That is probably what got him elected the second president of LSF, following the able administration
of Bob Andris. A new club appeared on the scene that year, represented by 12 members who drove all the
way from San Diego to see how the big boys flew sailplanes. They were called the Torrey Pines Gulls.
In 1972, Womens Lib was becoming the big thing and Barbara Henon liberated the big hardware.
Barbara's Club, the San Fernando Valley Silent Flyers, ably handled the organization of this meet. This
was the first meet to be held at the Mile Square site in Fountain Valley, Calif. The winning club was
from the North again, as the South Bay Soaring Society took the laurels. Will the South rise?
1973 was the year
for the South. The Torrey Pines Gulls took the Chicago Soaring NATS team award with Rod Smith, Mark
Smith and Col. Bob Thacker. Then August rolled, around, and it was LSF Tournament time again. Camarillo,
Calif., was the host city, and the LSF had the entire Oxnard Air Force Base. This was the first time
that speed was the big thing, and 8-10 lb. monsters were the rule. The little 5-6 oz. wing loaded (Standard
Class) gliders should have stayed home. The Torrey Pines Gulls came to prove that they were big boys
now. They won the first three positions and the team award. Buck Faure, the Gulls' president, was No.1
(King Golden Thumbs, as his daughter christened him). The Camarillo Flying Circus had this one as the
best team. Who will forget the mountain of barbecued ribs we consumed at the banquet-Sunday between
flights it was Rolaids, Turns, Bromo and Alka Seltzer.
Here it is, the Fifth Annual LSF Soaring
Tournament back at Mile Square, which in now under the control of the Fountain Valley, Calif., Parks
Dept. For the first time, we had to pay for the privilege of admission to a soaring site. The half-dollar
wasn't too bad, but at least they could have had the toilets less than three-quarters of a mile away.
This tournament was hosted by a rather new group on the soaring scene, the Southern California Soaring
Clubs, fondly known as SC2. It is Aug. 24-25
The half CDs in a more relaxed moment. At the Chicago S.O.A.R.
Nats, Dick launches Barbara's Cirrus. (Photo by Bill Coons)
Hugh Stock checks the
controls of his scale Diamant. (Photo by Chris Adams)
Lemon Payne launches
his Legion Air. (Photos by Paul Denson)
Yes, Virginia, there
is a thermal fairy.
Me, too, I flew. (Photo
by Paul Denson)
Buck Faure, the defending
LSF Tournament Champion, couldn't get his stuff together this year. His PRESBYTERIAN design, so successful
last year, will appear in a future issue of AAM. (Photo by Chris Adams)
Don Edberg flew a Duster
in Scale. A new kit from Airtronics. (Photo by Chris Adams)
No, not with sailplane
raised in victory, but rather a great catch of Pat Seal's Cirrus, which looped off the line. Fast reflexes!
(Photo by Chris Adams)
Mark! (Photo by Chris
Winch lines whip off silent sailplanes, now freed to fly-timed-fly.
Stopwatches snap at speed traps as soarers slither through the sunshinetimed- fly.
timer cries. "Mark your mark and make your target."
The hurly burly contest ,like slow motion-silent
flight. Here in leagues, they fly-League of Silent Flight.
Mark! they cry. MARK! they fly.
Five score of pilots participate on the square mile of asphalt (circles on asphalt for soft
landings)-"Slide an inch or slide a mile" says Schilling, half CD, while other half ... the Henon half.
.. draws diagrams on the chalkboard during the pilots' briefing-briefly all evening it took to register
and be briefed. Why? Lots of questions. Must be sure, for sure, for this is a biggie-a tournament-the
LSF Tournament. The mile (I'd walk a mile for a thermal) squares off against the soaring scores, while
scores of soarers score ... hit the
"And who flew?" asks the chorus. There was
Rick Walters (Super Trash elliptically tipped), and Lemon Payne (Legion Air-superb new kit). and Rodman
Smith (with Willow-Bee Wand in hand), and V-tailed Dale Nutter, and straw-hatted Col. Bob Thacker, and
frumpy-hatted Dave Shadel, and of course, the man (and here he is folks, fresh from the S.O.A.R. Nats
and AerOlympics) ....
And me, I flew too.
And curly haired dawn slumbered
not long in her haste to spread light upon the firmament ... exactly a mile square of it. When 10, came
the metal chariots carrying warriors (pugipilots) into the recreation center (a mile square arena) where
gladiatorially they toted slender weapons which penetrated the air like machines of the gods. But what
holds them back? Why tarry, brave men, bird men? Do they heed the Icaran warning with the rosy-fingered
sun still so low?
Schilling, half CD, scurries helter-skelter with seine line slipping everywhere.
He turns around, all akimbo, while the turnarounds fail. The auto mechanic acts instinctively and, before
you can turn around, the turnarounds are fixed.
MARK! they cry, as the warriors fly.
"An aside from our on-the-spot correspondent. What? Not there yet? Still sleeping! . Stay tuned
for an in-depth analysis a little later in our program."
And me, I flew, too ... after
I awoke, later.
Now Zeus breathed life into the air (a square mile of air) and the lower gods
(deities of the thermal) settled low upon the plain (and planes) of war and oversaw the combat. And
Dale of the Nutter did drink with the gods' cup and was justly rewarded with a MAX.
noun (abbrev.), a maximum score. Defined at the LSF contest under two categories. 1. A MAX of 10 minutes,
by which the flier, or pilot, sustained flight with his aircraft for ten (10) minutes, after which a
landing period of three (3) minutes was allowed. Cf. AMA task II. 2 A MAX of three (3) minutes, by
which the flier, or pilot, maintained flight with his aircraft for three (3) minutes from time of tow
... until the aircraft made initial contact with a ground-based object.
See also: Object, ground-based.
Q. And who else may have, given the hypothesis that a
maximum flight duration of ten (10) minutes was possible on Saturday Aug. 23, 1974 (during the hours
of 9:30 and 3:00 p.m.), achieved the distinction of flying a MAX (use the dictionary definition of MAX)?
Answer worth 25 points.
A. To repeat all the names would be moribund. We can achieve an
equitable realization of the factors, species and other things involved in winning the LSF Tournament
only by citing a few significant names. These would be (not necessarily in any order): D. O. Darnell,
Dale Nutter, Max Mills, Terry Malsbury and Smith.
No. Rodman maxed. br>
By this time, the Olympiad sat silent, while silent flight occurred.
"And now, an
interview by our crack reporter, who has just collared Schilling, half CD."
one, two, three. Hello, glider guiders everywhere. Today we're at Mile Square Recreation Center in sunny
Southern California. Dick Schilling, who, along with Barbara Henon, is co-Contest Director of this
meet, is here with me. Hello Dick."
"H i Pat." br>
&"Dick, why did you opt for 1
0 minutes plus Duration and not the normally preferred task of 10 minutes on the spot?"
you're flying Precision, you're flying Precision. When you're flying Duration, you're flying Duration.
The landing was the tie-breaker."
"As you all know, the landing circle out here is a 25·foot
circle with a Mil secured in the middle. TWQ measuring tapes are marked in points ... highest points
closest to the nail. When you land, you measure with the tape, then get your glider out of the circle.
"Here's Mark Smith. Let's try to get a word with him ..."
Fair Zeus' rays shone now
high in the heaven, as ...
"We've lost contact with our crack ... " br>
added heavy objects to their vehicles, to make them more like Theban missiles. And they stood at the
"reporter. Stay tuned for further reports. "
raised flags and shouted.
Like winged Mercury they flew ...
MARK! the stopwatches clicked as the Speed Event began. This
year, no monster KA6Es were present, each contestant apparently realizing the consequences of a. poor
trade-off in the all-important tasks of Duration and Precision.
"We interrupt this program
for a candid interview with Mark Smith, which was previously interrupted."
think of the Speed Event."
'Well, Pat, the Speed Event simulates wind. It makes the winning
airplane an all-around design. If you just had a straight 10·Minute Duration with a bonus landing, most
obviously the best 'airplane would have a very, very large wing area; very, very slow sink rate, and
to heck with the LID. It would be all sink rate - the slowest airplane to the ground would be the winner.
"So, if you had a person like Konrad Nierich who goes very, very fast all the time; well,
his model (the Tern, as published in July AAM) has a good LID but the sink rate's bad. So, when the
wind blows he has a very distinct advantage over the Olympic-type airplanes, which have very poor penetration.
So, when you throw the speed in there, it makes the airplane become an all-around airplane-fly good
in wind, fly good in calm, and if the wind doesn't blow, the Speed Event creates the wind.
much ballast weight are you carrying for the Speed Event?"
"Twelve oz., which brings the total
weight of my Windfree to 42 oz."
.... like zephyrs across the course, both toward the sun and
back, the glint as they turned like fire on steel weapons in the air.
MARK! The Speed Event
had just about concluded. Smith's time was the fastest, at 38 sec., with Rick Walters only a second
behind. Lemon Payne was in the low 40s and ...
Yes, me too, I flew fast! Beginner's luck, since
I was so green to this event (my first try at it) that I had to have someone explain what I was supposed
to do when I got off the line.
Q. If you were Dick Schilling, half CD, how would you define
the term, "creative sandbagging?"
A. If I were Dick Schilling, half CD, I'd define the term,
"creative sandbagging" by example. On Saturday, a certain well-known flier, with full knowledge of
the rules for the Speed Event, which specifically stated that, once off the line, the plane was to make
an immediate 1800 turn (and not attempt to ride any lift in the vicinity), then fly back over the winches,
and lastly to make a 900 turn onto the course, which was perpendicular to the towlines, utilized "creative
sandbagging." Upon encountering up air off the tow, he made his 1800 turn more a shallow slipping affair,
which enabled him to fly with his maximum LID in the thermal and slowly drift back (still in the thermal)
into an advantageously high position from which to start his speed run. That's "creative sandbagging."
Dick Schillinq, half CD, expressed his admiration for this sort of thing, since it takes talent. Mr.
Schilling and Ms. Henon ran the LSF Tournament in a wonderfully relaxed style, with no pressure on the
fliers. This made it a really enjoyable contest.
"Well, the day's flying is over. This is your
crack reporter signing off . til tomorrow morning."
Dateline: Sunday, Aug.
24, Mile Square Recreation Center, Fountain Valley, Calif. Today, the LSF entered its second day of
formal competition. With 125 contestants, the Tournament is second only in size to the Chicago S.O.A.R.
"And we now return you to our crack reporter. What's that? Still sleeping!
Stay tuned for bulletins as they happen."
And rosy-fingered dawn stretched out her soft
fingers through a veil of haze. Their weapons in strong lines on the ground, the warriors stood ready
to resume their battle. No champions stepped forward yet, and each man looked quietly toward the hazy
The position of this publication, like that of any news
media, is that it is the primary function and responsibility of the press to be a critic, and often
the adversary, of government. And, in years past when we felt something was wrong, we stated our opinion.
It is imperative that we must, at this moment, give pause for a thought which will have ramifications
throughout the soaring world. Our topic is the proper definition of team entries in a contest of the
caliber of the LSF Tournament. Reliable sources inform us that the winning team was not, as one would
expect, made up of individuals who were members of the same AMA-chartered club. Regrettably, the first-place
team consisted of three individuals who decided to make themselves a team entry only shortly before
the contest began.
Even more appalling is the fact that at least four of the other so-called
"teams" were not composed of individuals who were affiliates' of a recognized club, but rather what
we must assume to have been convenient alliances of compatible (and, of course, skilled) fliers. This
is wholly out of the accepted context of team competition and it is hoped that the LSF, or the CDs for
the '75 Tournament, give serious consideration to regulating closely the requirements for a team entry.
Sailplanes were a-flying now, the tarmac aglow with pretty rays of soft sun. Thermals
afoot across the towlines, like silent bubbles. All was sweetness and harmony in gliderland.
"In retrospect, our object in the contest was to have a contest where skill would count, where
the best fliers would win, and where luck wouldn't count.
"I think that the contest ... the
way we designed it, the best fliers came out on top." Quote from Dick Schilling, half CD.
"And here's our crack reporter, awake and aware."
"H i there!"
all fliers had completed their 10-Minute Duration and ThreeMinute Precision. Jim Wiseman pretty well
had Precision in the bag, while Oklahoma Dale Nutter V-tailed it into the top spot in Duration .
What about Standard Class?
The magazine litany of the winners:
Rick Pearson Dave Thornburg Richard Barker
Rodman Smith (the Father)
Speed got off at 3 o'clock.
A perfect score folks! Rick Walters (Remember him from Paul Denson's preface above?) astounded
the sports world, as well as a few modelers, by zinging a stupendous 2000 points in Speed (calculated
at 39 and 40 sec. on the timers' watches ... Mark!)
Lemon Payne flew that lightly loaded (5
oz. sq. ft.) Legion Air fast enough through the traps to secure second place .
And third place
was captured by ... Me too, I flew!
"Hi there! Mark my words, I'm here awake and aware to tell
you about the Scale sailplanes. I timed a beautiful flight for H ugh Stock, the eventual winner. His
Diamant (a SoarCraft kit, of course) was launched into some tricky air. There was a long-standing thermal
to the left of the runway and about a quarter of a mile out. Hugh got off the line ...
" .... and headed for the leftward lift.
"After only about three min., the
lift started to get sketchy, and Hugh, with my verbal assistance, opted for what looked like a good
piggyback spot to the right of the runway.
"Yes, he was getting pretty low, too ... maybe only
400 feet or so. Across the sink he slid, losing more ground in an attempt to get to the lift. Those
blokes were really pretty far out, maybe even to the edge of the field, and Hugh was getting really
low by now. As he crossed the edge of the runway, some minor lift was encountered.
at maybe 200 feet, things didn't look so good for Hugh's Diamant. He flew really well, though, in the
spotty lift, and soon the halfway point (five min.) was passed. But another full five min. from 200
feet in thermals so small that turning inside them was impossible?
"But mustached, amiable Stock
is a real champion, and he flew that sailplane as smoothly as a greased billiard ball on a pool table.
"Finally, hearts in throats, the Diamant was so low that the cockpit detail was starting to
show ... and there were still two min. left. At almost nine min., there just wasn't anymore lift to
be had, and H ugh came in for a good landing off to the side of the runway. (No precision landing at
all was required for the scale models. After all, why jeopardize them on the concrete?)
all was said and done, Hugh emerged victorious, with 14,034 total points; 163 static and 1722 flight
"D. O. Darnell was second by only eight points with his Glasflugel 604, and Lee Renaud
flew his attractive new Duster design (soon to be an Airtronics kit) to third place.
IS what happened in Scale."
As our crack reporter rides off into the sunset, the 1974 LSF Tournament
is at an end.
"And who won the title of LSF Tournament Champion," asks the chorus.