RF Cafe Homepage

Search AAR WebsiteSearch Airplanes and Rockets Website

 Copyright 2007-2030

Articles & Plans

Airplanes | Rockets | Kits

Boats | Cars | Trains

Helicopters | Electronics

Website

Host: Kirt Blattenberger

AMA 92498 | KB3UON

Sitemap | About AAR

Homepage Archive

Building & Flying 

Hints & Tips

Balsa | Airfoils

Silkspan & Dope

Engines & Motors

Air Modeling

C/L Capers | Ads

Model Rocketeer

Jetex | Cox | CO2

Personal Stuff

My Models | Radios

Woodworking

Astronomy | Peanuts

Suzy Homemaker

Parole Plaza | Photos

Just for Fun 

Comics & Humor

Crosswords | Stories

Vintage Magazine Articles 

American Modeler | Air Trails

American Aircraft Modeler

RC Modeler | Flying Aces

Boy's Life | Young Men

Saturday Evening Post

Pop Science | Pop Mechanics

Pop Electronics | Aero-Modeller

A Few Items for Sale

Editorial: R/C Models Today Are Just Too Expensive
September 1968 American Aircraft Modeler

Sept. 1968 American Aircraft Modeler

September 1968 American Aircraft Modeler magazine cover Table of Contents

These pages from vintage modeling magazines like Flying Aces, Air Trails, American Modeler, American Aircraft Modeler, Young Men, Flying Models, Model Airplane News, R/C Modeler, captured the era. All copyrights acknowledged.

Not all old adages are still true. Waaaay back in the last century, even as recently as the late 1990's and early 2000's, that is to say before the advent of 2.4 GHz, spread spectrum radio systems, brushless motors, and LiPo batteries for model use, you could make the argument proclaimed here in this American Aircraft Modeler magazine editorial that "R/C models today are just too expensive." Yes, it might apply to giant scale, competition models, and jets, but when adjusted for inflation, the cost of an entry level radio controlled airplane (or helicopter for that matter) is dirt cheap. You can but a ready-to-fly trainer with airplane, motor, battery, charger, and radio system for under $100 ($11.82 in 1968 money per the BLS Inflation Calculator). With so much stuff being built by Uyghur slave labor and other virtual slave labor in China where hopeless people commit suicide by jumping off production plant buildings, combined with a trade policy that includes undercutting American product prices, modeling has never been easier to get into.

Editorial

(R/C models today are just too expensive - in both monetary value and in the time invested - to risk their being wrecked by some idiot bootlegger.)

It has been something of a surprise to us to find that many flyers who operate (most of them legally!) on the amateur 50-54 MHz band don't know that there is a group of recommended spot frequencies set up by the AMA for such use - others may have heard about these spots but don't know what they are. Though they have been mentioned in this and other magazines before these are the spots and the ribbon colors to go with them: 53.10 MHz (black-brown); 53.20 MHz (black-red); 53.30 MHz (black-orange); 53.40 MHz (black-yellow); 53.50 MHz (black-green); 51.20 MHz (black-light blue); 52.04 MHz (black-violet).

The first five spots are for exclusive superheterodyne use, the last two for exclusive superregen use. This is the only R/C band where there is enough room to operate both hets and regens together (latter not allowed on 72 MHz). It should be evident that the significant feature of all the 50 mc ribbons is black. This is the "band designator," just as a white ribbon is utilized with certain ribbon colors to show specific spot frequencies on the 72-76 MHz band. You'll note the color sequence is the same as on 27 and 72; it starts with brown and follows the resistor color code thereafter. It was felt best to deviate a bit from the general scheme of employing brown for the lowest spot frequency, as has been done on both 27 and 72, to emphasize the fact that on 50, the two lowest spots are for regens only.

Some may ask why were these rather odd spots chosen. And why we can't use all the rest of that space in the 50 MHz band for R/C too. The AMA Frequency Committee spent much time weighing all the factors involved. These include harmonics from the 27-mc spots, image frequency spots of receivers, and other subtle matters we won't go into now. Just on the matter of images, most R/Cers don't know that their supposedly extremely-sharp-tuning superhet receiver can operate within a reasonable number of megahertz from adjacent spot frequencies - but that it is relatively wide open to a frequency two times the intermediate frequency of the receiver (generally about 900 KHz, and generally lower than the nominal receiver frequency) away. For example, a receiver on 53.10 would be vulnerable to a strong signal on about 52.20 MHz. But the AMA-suggested spots have taken this into account, and all the R/C spots are safe from interference of other nearby R/C transmitters.

As for using more space on the 50 MHz band - makers of 50 MHz gear now have to stock crystals for at least the five superhet spots - in addition to what they must carry for 27 and 72 MHz. Let's not ask them to stock a larger number! As for the flyers themselves, we have five spots on 27 MHz (six, if you count 27.255, which is not in very wide use for R/C), seven on 50 MHz, and five more on 72 - how many planes can you put in the air at one time, at anyone field?

So we do have recommended 50 MHz spots. Do you have to use them? No you don't. They are not required by the FCC, as are the spots on 27 and 72. But - you stand a darn good chance of shooting down a fellow modeler, if you use other spots. Similarly you stand just as good a chance of getting shot down yourself ... dig? The old-time users of 50 MHz have become used to checking other users of this band for frequency before turning on a transmitter. Many new-comers to 50 MHz just aren't that careful. But with ribbons and the recommended spots in use, things will be much safer all around.

While the 50 MHz spots aren't required by the FCC, they probably will be mandatory at AMA-sanctioned meets, since operation of two or more flight lines simultaneously makes precise frequency control necessary. Oddball frequencies won't do any more - as this writer learned to his sorrow last summer! Since they'll be mandatory at meets, we feel every R/C club should stress their use at club fields - where three or four 50-MHz transmitters can be in use at one time.

One last point on the use of 50 MHz RIC frequencies in general. Note that an FCC license is needed for such use-despite what you might hear from scofflaws (some of whom won't bother to obtain an FCC license for any frequencies). Perhaps we'll always have such bootleggers with us, but the FCC is cracking down harder and harder on unlicensed operations on the Citizen's Band spots. And they can (and do) monitor the ham bands as well. These stupid non-licensed operators - regardless of band - simply serve to give all R/Cers a bad name, and could lead to loss of R/C frequencies - to say nothing of their chances of a heavy fine or even a sojourn in jail. R/C models today are just too expensive - in both monetary value and in the time the builder invests in them - to risk their being wrecked by some idiot bootlegger, who is likely on an oddball frequency!

 

 

Posted January 21, 2023

About Airplanes & Rockets 

Kirt Blattenberger, Webmaster - Airplanes and RocketsKirt Blattenberger

Carpe Diem! (Seize the Day!)

Even during the busiest times of my
life I have endeavored to maintain
some form of model building activity.
This site has been created to help me chronicle my journey through a lifelong involvement in model aviation, which all began in Mayo, MD ...

Copyright 1996 - 2030

All trademarks, copyrights, patents, and other rights of ownership to images and text used on the Airplanes and Rockets website are hereby acknowledged.

Webmaster:                         Family Websites:

Kirt Blattenberger                 RF Cafe

BS Electrical Engineering       Equine Kingdom

Amateur Radio KB3UON

Model Aircraft Museum, AMA - Airplanes and Rockets